XRechnung

Frequently Asked Question

• 1. What is XRechnung?

  XRechnung is an XML-based invoice format preferred by German authorities, fulfilling the criteria of the European core calculation and being the response to the CEN standard (CEN/TC 434). Other formats, such as ZUGFeRD 2.0 or Factur-X, are expected to remain applicable for B2B transactions, but all suppliers for the German public administration will be obliged to switch to X-Rechnung.

  An XRechnung file can be sent via one of the many transmission channels, such as the German ZRE, OZG RE, and VPX platforms

• 2. Is e-invoicing mandatory in Germany?

  For now, all companies in selected states such as Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, Saarland and Hamburg that are doing business with public entities should use structured electronic invoices. B2B e-invoicing remains optional.

• 3. Who is liable to send e-invoices in Germany?

  All companies making B2G transactions in following states:

  • As of 27th November 2020, mandatory on federal level and in the federal state of Bremen.
  • As of 1 January 2022, B2G e-invoicing became mandatory in the federal states of Saarland, Hamburg and Baden Württemberg
  • As of 1 April 2023, B2G e-invoicing will become mandatory in the federal state of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania
  • As of January 2024, B2G e-invoicing will become mandatory in the federal state of Rhineland-Palatinate
  • As of 18 April 2024, B2G e-invoicing will become mandatory in the federal state of Hessen

• 4. What is an e-invoice and how does it differ from an unstructured invoice?

  An e-invoice is an electronic invoice document in a structured, machine-readable format that enables automated processing. In contrast, unstructured invoices, such as PDFs or paper documents, are only readable by humans and require more effort to read (e.g. with OCR or a PDF extractor). Structured formats such as XML, UBL or EDIFACT fulfil legal requirements and promote interoperability.

• 5. Which electronic formats must be accepted and supported by invoice recipients?

  Since 1 January 2025, companies have been obliged to accept and technically process electronic invoices in structured format in accordance with CEN standard EN 16931. This means: If an e-invoice that complies with CEN standard EN 16931 (including current versions of XRechnung or ZUGFeRD) is sent, the recipient's consent is not required - the e-invoice may not be rejected.

• 6. Under what circumstances can an invoice be rejected by the recipient?

  The sending of electronic invoices that do not correspond to the structured format in accordance with CEN standard EN 16931 requires the consent of the recipient and can therefore be rejected by the recipient if this is not available.

  During the transitional period, however, the invoice issuer can continue to issue invoices in paper form without the recipient's consent.

• 7. Do I have to agree on a format with my business partners for the exchange of electronic invoices?

  Invoice recipients must be able to process electronic invoices that are compliant with CEN standard EN 16931. Agreement on a specific format is not mandatory, but can increase the efficiency of the invoicing process.

• 8. Which invoice formats am I likely to receive from my business partners?

  You should always be prepared to receive and process electronic invoice formats that comply with CEN standard EN 16931. The market study on the implementation of mandatory e-invoicing in Germany, conducted jointly with Fraunhofer IAO, provides insight into which formats are popular for invoicing → to the study.

• 9. Will I still be able to exchange invoices in PDF format after 2025?

  Yes, PDF invoices can continue to be exchanged until 31 December 2026 with the consent of the recipient. For companies with an annual turnover of less than EUR 800,000, this option applies until 31 December 2027.

• 10. How can consent to receive other invoice formats (e.g. paper or PDF) be given or determined?

  There is no formal requirement for consent, so it can also be given implicitly or tacitly, e.g. by paying the invoice.

• 11. Which transmission channels are prescribed for the exchange of e-invoices?

  In principle, there are no legal requirements for electronic transmission, or EDI interfaces, web portals, PEPPOL and e-mail channels can be used. When choosing a suitable transmission channel, it makes sense to differentiate between the size and type of business partner with whom you exchange invoices.

  • A technical EDI interface between the invoice issuer's IT system and the invoice recipient's IT system (classic EDI) is already common practice, especially in large companies, regardless of the e-invoicing obligation, and is particularly suitable for business partners with whom many invoices are exchanged.
  • Web portals (WebEDI) offer the option of filling out an invoice form via a web-based portal, from which a legally compliant invoice format can be automatically created and sent to the recipient. This transmission channel is particularly useful for SME partners.
  • E-mail as a classic transmission channel is ideal for business partners with whom very few e-invoices are exchanged.

• 12. Are there any risks when deducting input tax, e.g. in cases of multiple submissions of invoices?

  Since 2011, the tax authorities have waived specific technical requirements in relation to the transmission of invoices, provided that the authenticity of the origin and the integrity of the content are guaranteed by internal control systems. This also applies to the input tax deduction associated with these invoices.

  The fears of a double sales tax liability for invoices sent in paper and electronic form have already been dispelled by a letter from the Federal Ministry of Finance dated 2 July 2012. Even if multiple copies of the same invoice with identical content are sent without duplicate or copy labelling, the supplier is not liable for VAT more than once.

  It is important to note that the authenticity of the origin, the integrity of the content and the legibility of the invoice must be guaranteed by an internal control procedure, unless a qualified electronic signature is used or the invoice is transmitted via electronic data interchange (EDI).

  Every entrepreneur is free to decide how to ensure the authenticity of the origin, the integrity of the content and the legibility of the invoice, e.g. an internal control procedure can be used to create a reliable audit trail between the invoice and the service.

• 13. Can currently used formats such as iDoc, EDIFACT, X12, VDA or ODETTE still be used?

  Existing formats can continue to be used as long as they correspond to the structured electronic format of an electronic invoice in accordance with Section 14 (1) sentence 6 UStG:

  "The structured electronic format of an electronic invoice

  1.     is required to comply with the European standard for electronic invoicing and the list of corresponding syntaxes in accordance with Directive 2014/55/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 April 2014 on electronic invoicing in public procurement (OJ L 133, 6.5.2014, p. 1) or

  2.     can be agreed between the invoice issuer and the invoice recipient. The prerequisite is that the format enables the correct and complete extraction of the information required under this Act from the electronic invoice into a format that corresponds to the standard under number 1 or is interoperable with it."

  Which formats are interoperable can be determined from a technical point of view: It must contain all mandatory fields specified by the CEN standard and be convertible into a format that conforms to the CEN standard. If the aforementioned EDI formats iDoc, EDIFACT, X12, VDA or ODETTE are supplemented by any missing mandatory data, interoperability should be available.

• 14. Where can I find the requirements of CEN standard EN 16931?

  The European standard on E-Invoicing (EN 16931) can be viewed on the official website of the European Commission:
  https://ec.europa.eu/digital-building-blocks/sites/display/DIGITAL/Obtaining+a+copy+of+the+European+standard+on+eInvoicing

• 15. Which formats are compatible with the CEN standard EN 16931?

  There are various formats that fulfil the requirements of the semantic data model of the European standard EN 16931. This data model was specified for the syntaxes UBL 2.1 (Universal Business Language) and CII D16B (Cross Industry Invoice). The member states can introduce their own standards or concretisation of the standard (so-called CIUS) on the basis of this standard or even extend it. Accordingly, there are several standards throughout Europe that fulfil the requirements of the standard. In Germany, the most commonly used formats are XRechnung and ZUGFeRD. 

• 16. How can I determine whether the format I am using is interoperable with the CEN standard?

  A format is considered interoperable if the information required under VAT law can be converted into a format that complies with CEN standard EN 16931 without any loss of information. A technical check can help to identify missing mandatory data.

• 17. How can specific information or industry-specific data that exceeds the requirements of the CEN standard EN 16931 be included in my invoice?

  The respective responsible organisations deal with the further development of the CEN standard EN 16931 as well as national adaptations of the standard (so-called CIUS) or extensions. Comarch is actively involved in the design of e-invoicing specifications across countries and is also involved in the further development of e-invoicing standards in the B2B context in Germany.

  If you find that certain information or validations are not currently covered by the standard, please do not hesitate to contact us. We will bring such requirements to the relevant working groups. Please note, however, that changes to the standard are typically associated with a longer implementation period due to fixed release cycles and extensive coordination and approval processes with all EU member states.

• 18. What happens if the PDF part of ZUGFeRD contains different information than the structured part?

  It has been officially announced that the structured part of a ZUGFeRD invoice has priority over the non-structured PDF part. In case of doubt, the structured part will always apply. It therefore makes sense to use only the structured part of the invoice for posting and archiving purposes.

• 19. How can a small company make structured (machine-readable) files human-readable?

  Common browsers or text editors can be used to make structured files readable. There are also special software tools that enable a user-friendly display, just as a corresponding programme is required to display PDF files.

• 20. Is there a centralised government platform for the exchange of structured invoices?

  There is no centralised government platform for the exchange of structured invoices. Business partners are free to choose which transmission channel they wish to use. The exchange of structured invoices attached to an e-mail or the use of web portals is also possible.

• 21. Which invoice types are not covered by the e-invoicing obligation?

  The e-invoicing obligation applies to domestic B2B transactions. The correction of an e-invoice must also be made in the form prescribed for this. Intra-Community invoices are currently not affected by the obligation.

• 22. What happens if I am not legally compliant?

  No penalties are currently planned. However, an invoice that is not issued in accordance with the regulations may result in no input tax deduction being granted in accordance with Section 15 (1) sentence 1 no. 1 of the German Value Added Tax Act (UStG). In addition, conflicts may arise between business partners, for example with regard to payment and possible reminders.

• 23. Why is electronic invoicing mandatory in Germany - and what comes next?

  The e-invoicing obligation in Germany is part of a larger EU project: The ViDA initiative aims to modernise the European Union's value added tax system. It is therefore planned that in future electronic invoices will be reported to an IT system of the government of the individual states for the purpose of tax audits. The EU countries will probably in turn have to report their collected data to an EU system.

• 24. How do I implement the legal requirements for e-invoicing?

  Get an overview with the roadmap for the smooth introduction of e-invoicing in Germany and receive practical tips on how to implement e-invoicing in a legally compliant and efficient manner and integrate it into your existing processes.

  Discuss your requirements and wishes with our Legal & Consulting team now and fully utilise the potential of e-invoicing:

  Make a contact

• 25. Can sending e-invoices via EDI make it possible to completely dispense with paper invoices?

  Yes, in most European countries it is legally permitted to replace paper invoices with electronic invoices, especially if these are sent via EDI systems . The EU Directive 2010/45/EU supports this transition, and many countries have adapted their legislation accordingly. In Germany, paper invoices will in future be classed as "other invoices" and will gradually no longer be permitted for exchange. 

• 26. Why is e-invoicing so heavily regulated by the legislator?

  E-invoicing is heavily regulated by law, as it enables invoices to be checked in real time for compliance with tax regulations. This helps to combat tax fraud and close the VAT gap. Countries with high financial requirements or high tax evasion tend to introduce stricter e-invoicing regulations.

• 27. What are the requirements of EU Directive 2014/55/EU for electronic invoicing?

  EU Directive 2014/55/EU obliges public contracting authorities in the EU to be able to receive and process electronic invoices. It defines a uniform standard for e-invoices in order to improve interoperability and efficiency in public procurement.

• 28. Do e-invoices have to be archived in electronic form?

  Yes, if a company switches to electronic invoices, it is legally obliged to archive them in electronic form. This ensures traceability and compliance with tax retention obligations. You can find more information on this in the GOBD 2.0 of the legislator. 

• 29. Is Comarch E-Invoicing suitable as a global solution for multinational companies?

  Yes, Comarch E-Invoicing is designed for multinational companies and supports compliance with international e-invoicing regulations. The solution enables the digital exchange of invoices with authorities (B2G), companies (B2B) and customers (B2C) worldwide and ensures compliance with local legal requirements.