How to Implement Loyalty Effectively in Ecommerce

We are all familiar with loyalty programs, but what we might not realize is that certain types of businesses are best suited to take advantage of different loyalty program features and rules while other features might not be worth pursuing. Ecommerce companies may want to maximize their loyalty program in a way that makes sense for customers and clients. This first requires an understanding of what goes into the design and operation of an ecommerce loyalty program. Once we understand how these ecommerce only programs differ from traditional loyalty programs, we can then focus in on the strengths of that program and how to maximize those strengths for the biggest ROI and customer engagement.

Ecommerce Loyalty Program Benefits

Loyalty programs are important for Ecommerce companies for several reasons as they differ from traditional loyalty programs in several ways beyond just the online-only aspect:

  1. Data-Driven: Ecommerce companies have access to a wealth of customer data, which allows them to create personalized loyalty programs and offer targeted rewards and promotions. Traditional loyalty programs may not have the same level of data-driven capabilities.
  2. Instant Gratification: Ecommerce loyalty programs often offer instant gratification through points, discounts, or other rewards that can be redeemed immediately. Traditional loyalty programs may require customers to accumulate points or other rewards over time before they can be redeemed.
    Greater reach: Ecommerce loyalty programs have the potential to reach a wider audience than traditional loyalty programs, as they can be promoted and accessed online 24/7 from anywhere in the world.
  3. Emphasis on Customer Experience: Ecommerce companies often prioritize the customer experience, which is reflected in their loyalty programs. This can be seen through personalized recommendations, exclusive content, and other perks that enhance the customer experience.
  4. Flexibility: Ecommerce loyalty programs are often more flexible than traditional loyalty programs, allowing customers to earn and redeem rewards in a variety of ways, such as through social media engagement, online activity or referrals.
  5. Lower Costs: Ecommerce loyalty programs are often less expensive to implement and maintain than brick and mortar loyalty programs, since they do not require physical infrastructure and can be managed more efficiently.

Building and Running a Successful Ecommerce Loyalty Program

As the name states, ecommerce programs feature online companies who are already using some form of ecommerce software. This foundation of the business can already be a deciding factor in how you proceed with an ecommerce loyalty program. When designing and launching a loyalty program, ecommerce companies may overlook several key factors that can impact the program's success. Below are some mistakes that ecommerce companies make when building out loyalty programs.

  1. Failing to Align the Program with Business Objectives: Loyalty programs should be aligned with the company's overall business objectives such as increasing sales, improving customer retention, or boosting customer lifetime value. If the loyalty program is not aligned with these objectives, it may not be effective in achieving its goals.
  2. Ignoring Customer Preferences: Successful loyalty programs are designed with the customer in mind. Companies may overlook customer preferences when designing the program, leading to a lack of engagement and participation. It is important to conduct research and gather insights on what customers want and need from a loyalty program.
  3. Not Offering Valuable Rewards: The rewards offered by a loyalty program should be valuable and relevant to customers. If the rewards are not compelling or meaningful, customers may not be motivated to participate in the program.
  4. Complexity and Friction in the Program: Loyalty programs should be easy to understand and use. If the program is overly complex or requires a lot of effort to participate, customers may lose interest or become frustrated.
  5. Lack of Communication and Promotion: Ecommerce companies may overlook the importance of communicating the program and promoting it to customers. If customers are not aware of the program or its benefits, they may not participate.
  6. Inadequate Tracking and Measurement: Ecommerce companies should track and measure the effectiveness of the loyalty program over time. If the program is not generating the desired results, it may be necessary to make changes or adjustments.
  7. Integration: Seamlessly plug in your loyalty program into your existing tech stack for seamless integration and create a simple path of how your data flows to ensure customers receive that real-time gratification and interactions can be reacted to automatically.

While it is important to consider all of the above when designing and implementing a loyalty program, ecommerce companies may overlook important factors that can impact the program's success. Below are mistakes that many ecommerce companies make when running a loyalty program.

  1. Failing to Update and Refresh the Program: Over time, customer preferences and behaviors may change, and the loyalty program should be updated and refreshed to stay relevant. Failing to refresh the program can lead to a lack of engagement and participation.
  2. Not Personalizing the Program or Leveraging Customer Data: Customer data is a powerful tool for optimizing any loyalty program. Personalization is key to driving engagement and loyalty. Leveraging customer data to improve the program's effectiveness through personalized communication to drive engagement will ensure customers feel valued in the program.
  3. Lack of Communication and Engagement: Ecommerce companies may miss opportunities to communicate with customers about the program and engage with them through targeted marketing campaigns and promotions.
  4. Poor Customer Service: Customer service is an essential part of the customer experience and can impact loyalty program participation. Providing excellent customer service to support the loyalty program can be a deciding factor between competing programs for customers.
  5. Not Offering New and Exciting Rewards: Over time, customers may become bored with the same rewards and benefits. Many companies overlook the importance of offering new and exciting rewards to keep customers engaged and motivated.

By addressing these common mistakes and continually optimizing the loyalty program, ecommerce companies can maximize the effectiveness of the program and drive long-term engagement and loyalty.

Ecommerce vs In-store Loyalty Program Advantages & Disadvantages

The most successful features of ecommerce loyalty programs are those that offer valuable rewards, personalized experiences, and engaging gamification features. By providing customers with incentives to remain loyal and engaged, ecommerce companies can build long-term relationships with their customers and increase their revenue over time. Here are some of the most effective features:

  1. Points-Based Rewards: Points-based systems are among the most popular and effective loyalty program features. Customers earn points for purchases and other actions, which they can then redeem for rewards such as discounts, free products, or exclusive access to events or content.
  2. Tiered Rewards: Tiered systems offer increasing rewards as customers reach higher levels of loyalty. For example, customers may start out as "bronze" members and earn basic rewards, but as they make more purchases or engage with the brand in other ways, they can progress to "silver" or "gold" status and receive more valuable rewards.
  3. Personalization: Personalized rewards are highly effective at driving customer engagement and loyalty. By offering tailored rewards based on customers' purchase history and preferences, ecommerce companies can make their customers feel valued and appreciated.
  4. Gamification: Gamification features like badges and progress bars can make loyalty programs more engaging and enjoyable for customers. By creating a sense of achievement and competition, gamification features can motivate customers to make repeat purchases and engage with the brand in other ways.
  5. Social Sharing: Loyalty programs that incorporate social sharing features, such as referral bonuses or rewards for sharing on social media, can help ecommerce companies reach new customers and increase brand awareness.

These features are not always exclusive to ecommerce loyalty programs and as such are being utilized by hybrid model companies who operate both ecommerce and brick and mortar locations. Some of these potential disadvantages that ecommerce only companies must overcome are:

  1. Lack of Human Interaction: Ecommerce loyalty programs may lack the personal touch and human interaction that customers can experience in a brick-and-mortar store and as such can also offer a higher level of customer service.
  2. Limited Physical Touchpoints: Ecommerce loyalty programs may not have the same physical touchpoints that brick-and-mortar loyalty programs can offer, such as in-store events or personalized interactions with sales associates.
  3. Increased Competition: Ecommerce loyalty programs may face more competition than brick and mortar loyalty programs, as customers have a wide range of online options to choose from and there are already national brands dominating some spaces.
  4. Dependence on Technology: Ecommerce loyalty programs are heavily dependent on technology, and any technical issues or disruptions can impact the customer experience. This is also why integration for your loyalty program into your existing tech stack is essential.
  5. Shipping and Logistics Challenges: Ecommerce loyalty programs may face challenges related to shipping and logistics, such as delays or damaged products, which can impact the customer experience and loyalty. Brick-and-mortar programs can offer locations in-store during customer checkout.
  6. Privacy Concerns: Ecommerce companies must prioritize privacy and security concerns related to customer data, which can impact the design and implementation of loyalty programs. Companies must use that data wisely to eliminate customer concerns so that they feel their data being used is valuable.

Future of Ecommerce Loyalty

To combat the disadvantages of lacking Brick & Mortar locations, the future of ecommerce loyalty programs is likely to involve greater personalization, multi-channel integration, and a focus on sustainability, gamification, and innovative technologies such as blockchain. By staying attuned to consumer preferences and behaviors, ecommerce companies can continue to develop and refine loyalty programs that drive customer engagement, retention, and revenue. Some potential trends and developments that may shape the future of ecommerce loyalty programs:

  1. Greater Personalization: As ecommerce companies gather more customer data, loyalty programs are likely to become even more personalized and tailored to individual preferences and behaviors. This may involve using artificial intelligence and machine learning to analyze customer data and recommend rewards and incentives based on individualized insights.
  2. Multi-Channel Integration: Ecommerce companies are likely to integrate their loyalty programs across multiple channels, including online and offline sales channels, mobile apps, and social media platforms. This will help to create a seamless, omnichannel customer experience and make it easier for customers to earn and redeem rewards across all touchpoints.
  3. Increased Emphasis on Sustainability: As consumers become more environmentally conscious, ecommerce loyalty programs may incorporate sustainability-focused rewards and incentives. This could include rewards for eco-friendly behavior such as recycling or using reusable packaging, or offering discounts on sustainable products.
  4. Gamification and Experiential Rewards: Ecommerce companies may increasingly use gamification and experiential rewards to engage and motivate customers. This could involve offering virtual experiences, exclusive events, or other rewards that offer unique and memorable experiences.
  5. Blockchain Technology: Blockchain technology offers potential benefits for loyalty programs, such as increased security and transparency, as well as the ability to create a decentralized loyalty program that is not tied to any single company or platform. As blockchain technology becomes more mainstream, we may see more ecommerce loyalty programs leveraging this technology.

Loyalty Program ROI

Keeping all of this in mind, companies must focus on the big picture for their loyalty program. The loyalty program ROI and in order to generate strong ROI companies should prioritize the following:

  1. Clear Goals and Metrics: Companies should set clear goals and metrics for their loyalty programs, such as customer retention rates, average order value, and customer lifetime value. This will help them measure the success of their program and make data-driven decisions to improve it.
  2. Personalization: Ecommerce companies should strive to create a personalized and engaging loyalty program experience for their customers. This can include offering personalized rewards, personalized communications, and personalized recommendations based on customer behavior and preferences.
  3. Easy to Use and Understand: Loyalty programs should be easy to use and understand, with clear instructions and guidelines for earning and redeeming rewards. This will help reduce confusion and frustration among customers, and make it easier for them to engage with the prog ram.
  4. Multiple Ways to Earn and Redeem Rewards: Companies should offer multiple ways for customers to earn and redeem rewards, such as through purchases, referrals, social media engagement, reviews and more. This will help keep customers engaged and motivated to continue participating in the program by other means than just purchases to form that emotional loyalty connection.
  5. Regular Communication: Ecommerce companies should communicate regularly with customers about their loyalty program, such as through email, push notifications, or in-app messages. This will help keep customers informed about their rewards and upcoming promotions, and encourage them to continue engaging with the program. At the same time, over communication must be avoided to ensure customers are not bothered by the program only benefited.
  6. Test and Iterate: Companies should regularly test and iterate their loyalty program, using data and customer feedback to make improvements and optimize the program for better ROI. A/B testing of promotions, campaigns and messaging should be conducted to ensure strategies are aligned with customer desires.

Examples of Strong Ecommerce Loyalty Programs

There are many successful ecommerce loyalty programs on the market today. Everyone is familiar with the largest ones today such as Amazon, Walmart and Sephora but there are others out there that have worked hard to differentiate themselves from their competition and exist in the same spaces as the companies who are driving over half of all internet sales in the US today. Some examples of these companies are:

Groupon Select: Groupon is a daily deals site that offers a subscription-based loyalty program called Groupon Select. Members pay an annual fee to receive exclusive discounts, free shipping, and early access to deals.  

Third Love Rewards: Third Love is an online clothing retailer that offers a loyalty program called Hooked Rewards. Members earn points for purchases, referrals, and social media engagement, which can be redeemed for discounts, free shipping, and exclusive access to sales and events.

How Comarch Can Help

As we have shown, it does not matter if you are starting on your loyalty journey or looking to make a change – the time is always right to continue exploring and educating yourself on the latest trends in the ecommerce loyalty industry. Comarch has the tools and expertise ready to transform your initiative and bring it to the next level. Explore more to learn which loyalty program platform is right for you and which added services you might also be interested in. Checkout our automated demos to explore what the platform has to offer or speak with our experts today to learn more about our platform or strategy services.

Tell Us Your Case 💬

Upcoming RFP? More info about product and services? Talk integrations? Need a price estimation?

Set up a 30-minute discovery call with our loyalty experts


Customer loyalty tips
straight to your inbox

Join the other 10 000 subscribers to start receiving:

Educational MaterialsInspiring Success Stories  

Trending Event News

Please wait